Reese's

Peanut Butter Cups White Creme

165 g, $2.42/100g

Gay Lea

Grass Fed Salted Butter

250 g, $3.60/100g

Reese's

Minis Peanut Butter Cups Candy

210 g, $1.90/100g

Reese's

Peanut Butter Cups Dark Chocolate

165 g, $2.42/100g

Almond Butter, 100% Smooth

765 g, $2.22/100g

Reese's

Miniatures Peanut Butter Cups Candy

230 g, $1.74/100g

No Name

Salted Butter

454 g, $1.32/100g

Reese's

Peanut Butter Cups Candy

46 g, $3.89/100g

Sunbutter

Sun Butter Spread Sunflower Butter, No-Sugar

454 g, $1.98/100g

Reese's

Peanut Butter Cup Candy

184 g, $3.53/100g

Nuts to You

Almond Hazelnut Butter

365 g, $3.70/100g

Reese's

Peanut Butter Cups Milk Chocolate

165 g, $2.42/100g

PC Blue Menu

Just Almonds Smooth Almond Butter

340 g, $2.65/100g

Nuttin' But Spreads Almond Butter Smooth

365 g, $2.74/100g

Nuts to You

Organic Pumpkin Seed Butter

250 g, $3.40/100g

Wowbutter

100% Peanut Free Spread

1 kg, $1.20/100g

No Name

Unsalted Butter

454 g, $1.32/100g

Gay Lea

Spreadables Butter With Canola Oil

227 g, $2.42/100g

Nuts to You

Cashew Butter, Smooth

500 g, $3.20/100g

Spreads Cashew Butter Smooth 365 g

365 g, $2.47/100g

Lactantia

Salted Butter

454 g, $1.10/100g

Creamy Almond Butter, No Stir

365 g, $2.74/100g

Nuts to You

Sunflower Seed Butter, Smooth

500 g, $1.50/100g

Kraft

Smooth Peanut Butter

1 kg, $0.80/100g

Savor

Grass-Fed Butter Salted

227 g, $4.09/100g

Shady Maple Farms

Maple Butter

260 g, $4.80/100g

Earth Balance

Original Buttery Spread

425 g, $1.72/100g

Nuts to You

Almond Butter, Smooth

365 g, $3.70/100g

Sunflower Seed Butter

365 g, $1.64/100g

Lactantia

Salted Butter Sticks

4x113.0 g, $1.99/100g

Sunbutter

Original

454 g, $1.98/100g

Earth Balance

Soy Free Buttery Spread

425 g, $1.72/100g

Nuts to You

Pistachio Butter Smooth

250 g, $6.40/100g

Kraft

Only Peanuts All Natural Smooth Peanut Butter

750 g, $1.07/100g

Nuts to You

Rainforest Nut Butter with Coconut

500 g, $3.20/100g

No Name

Smooth Peanut Butter

1 kg, $0.60/100g

Nutiva

Organic Coconut Oil With Non-Dairy Butter Flavour

414 ml, $3.07/100ml

Kraft

Smooth Light Peanut Butter

1 kg, $0.80/100g

Barney Butter

Almond Butter Smooth

284 g, $3.87/100g

Gay Lea

Unsalted Butter

454 g, $1.98/100g

Gay Lea

Salted Butter

454 g, $1.98/100g

No Name

Smooth Peanut Butter

500 g, $0.60/100g

President's Choice

Country Churned Salted Butter

454 g, $1.76/100g

Nuts to You

Almond Cashew Butter, Smooth

365 g, $3.70/100g

Kraft

Only Peanuts All Natural Peanut Butter With Sea Salt

750 g, $1.07/100g

Savor

Grass-Fed Butter Unsalted 82 % M.F.

227 g, $4.09/100g

PC Organics

Organic Smooth Peanut Butter

500 g, $1.10/100g

Lactantia

Cultured Unsalted Butter

4x113.5 g, $1.98/100g

Becel

Salted Plant Butter

454 g, $1.32/100g

Lactantia

Unsalted Butter

454 g, $1.10/100g

President's Choice

Country Churned Unsalted Butter

454 g, $1.76/100g

Kraft

Smooth Peanut Butter

2 kg, $0.75/100g

Gay Lea

Butter Sticks, Salted

454 g, $1.98/100g

Woolwich

Sea Salted Goat Butter

250 g, $3.60/100g

Kraft

Extra Creamy Peanut Butter

1 kg, $0.80/100g